In her career Amy recorded 901 kills, 891 digs and 397 blocks. She was the SLIAC Player of the Year in volleyball in 2000 and 2001. She was voted to the SLIAC FirstTeam All-Conference in 2000 and 2001. During her four years at Fontbonne, Amy's team went 76-27 and won the SLIAC Championship in 2000 and 2001. Amy is the career leader at Fontbonne for blocks with 397. She set the single season record for blocks at Fontbonne with 119 in 2000.
In basketball, Amy was the SLIAC Newcomer of the Year in 1998-99. She was voted SLIAC First-Team All-Conference all four years of her career. Amy was the SLIAC Player of the Year in 2000-01. For career, Amy averaged 16 points and 8 rebounds a game and shot 53 % from the field. Amy is the SLIAC's third all-time leading scorer with 1,628 points. Amy holds the following Fontbonne career records; most points (1,628), most rebounds (788), most consecutive games (103) and most FG's (664).
Amy was inducted into the SLIAC Hall of Fame in 2007.